Digital Access Pass vs. Wishlist Member and How to Choose Good Software

Choosing the best plugins or web apps to power your businesses tech system can be a big challenge at times.

There’s a dizzying array of choices for almost anything that you’d want to do through your website in terms of functionality, and when you come across two or more pieces of software that do almost the same thing, deciding between the options based on their feature sets alone can lead you into some frustrating trouble.

Let’s look at one example that will lead to one of the most helpful tactics I’ve found for choosing the right software and steering clear of software that could waste your time and money.

If you have a WordPress site and you’re interested in creating a paid only access member’s area to deliver an online program that you’re selling, the two most popular plugin options to accomplish that are Digital Access Pass (DAP) and WishList Member.

I get a lot of questions from people looking for help in trying to make the decision between these two plugins, and it’s understandable: they accomplish nearly the same end result and their feature sets are somewhat similar.

When I get this question about using DAP or Wishlist Member, my answer always comes down to choosing DAP, and here’s why:

The two plugins have similar feature sets, but as you look more closely between the two, DAP has a handful of additional features that are really nice to have, like being able to have customers go through the purchase process right on your site, flexible content “dripping” (i.e., automated content publishing schedules), and having an integrated affiliate tracking system.

To be clear, Wishlist Member does have the ability to drip content, but I’ve heard a lot of people say that they get frustrated with it because they can’t drip content the exact way they want to. In contrast, setting up the exact kind of drip schedule you want in DAP is quite easy.

Feature differences are one thing, but here’s the more important differentiating factor between the two plugins: Wishlist Member has been known to have a lot of bugs and their customer support has gotten a lot of bad reviews.

The combination of bugs plus bad customer support should be a big red flag for you, particularly when you’re trying to decide on software that will be part of the foundation of the way your business makes money.

Bugs and poor customer support often lead to high frustration, a lot of wasted time, angry customers (your customers that is), increased time spent on answering requests for help from your customers, and lost money.

Over the years I’ve seen many, many people use plugins that are vital to their business that have bugs and bad support, and the result is never pretty.

Software is only as good as it’s customer support is. A certain amount of bugs can be tolerated, worked through, and forgiven if the customer support people take really good care of you throughout the whole process and solve the problem quickly.

With DAP, the feature set is very strong, the software itself is solid, and their customer support is fantastic.

I’ve actually never heard anyone mention anything negative about their support, and my own experience with them has been great.

DAP currently costs about $70 more than Wishlist Member, but in my opinion, it’s well worth that extra bit of money.

For a little bit more money you’ll get a better feature set, better software, and amazing support. That means you get to avoid heaps of frustration and get on with the business of delivering awesome content to your customers instead of getting bogged down with bugs and support tickets.

Outside of the decision between these two specific plugins, when you’re trying to decide on any software for your business, remember to do some research not just on the feature sets but also on what people are saying about each piece of software and its support.

That will go a long way towards you making solid software decisions for your business.

15 Responses to “Digital Access Pass vs. Wishlist Member and How to Choose Good Software”

  1. Rena Hedeman September 20, 2012 at 6:58 pm #

    As always, Forest, your info and advice is SO helpful! I especially love the way you explain things in a straight-forward, easy-to-understand manner – you don’t get all jargony with the technical stuff. You’re basically a God-send to those of us with our own business who aren’t tech geniuses. I’m loving your course, by the way – with your step-by-step explanations, I’m actually getting the hang of it and don’t feel so intimidated by tech anymore! One step at a time…

    Thank you, Forest!

    • Forest Linden September 20, 2012 at 8:08 pm #

      Hey Rena :) So glad that I’m able to help you on your tech and business path, and it’s awesome to hear that you don’t feel so intimidated by tech stuff anymore. That warms my heart! Keep going one step at a time :)

      • Rena Hedeman September 21, 2012 at 1:48 am #

        Well, I still feel intimidated by some tech stuff still (and probably always will, since it’s always changing!) But that’s why I have my Tech Husband! :)

  2. Katie Adler September 21, 2012 at 4:58 am #

    I was just talking to a friend about this today! She is using S2–any thoughts???

    Thank you so much!

    Sincerely,

    Katie

    • Forest Linden September 26, 2012 at 6:34 pm #

      S2 has a pretty good feature set and is a good free plugin option, but there’s a couple things to keep in mind: 1) in general I tend to avoid free plugins when they will perform an important function in a business, like process payments, protect content, and deliver a program you’re selling
      online.

      The reason is that the support for free plugins will almost always be much less reliable, helpful, and fast. That means that when you have problems
      arise, such as during a launch of your product or program, you could get into some trouble if you’re relying on support from a free plugin. There’s just not as much motivation for developers to help folks who haven’t paid them anything.

      I’ve seen many people get into this kind of trouble from using free plugins for important things on their sites. Some free plugins are fine to use for unimportant things, but I recommend avoiding them for key parts of your business.

      Second, S2 doesn’t allow you to easily do content dripping inherently. You can set it up to drip content, but you’ll need to install a third party
      plugin and you’ll also need to now some PHP code so that you can edit and write a bit of code to get things working.

      That’s not a great solution for most people, and content dripping is usually pretty important for people selling online programs.

      So, those two things alone would be enough reason in my mind to not use S2 and spend a little money on DAP so that you know you’ve got a solid
      solution with customer support you can count on.

      Hope this helps :)

      ~Forest

  3. Scott Scanlon September 26, 2012 at 6:18 pm #

    Thought I would share our experience. We just recently (the last 2 weeks) made a switch in our membership software from S2Member to DAP. We first moved to Wishlist but found the same things you mentioned above. One of the biggest challenges for us was a 1 to many relationship on the product level. That’s tougher to do in WishList. DAP while a little more robust in that area still has it’s quirks. To get up and running quick (to test a concept) I think S2Member is better than either Wishlist or DAP, but long term based on what we’ve found DAP looks to be a better solution.

    • Forest Linden September 26, 2012 at 6:32 pm #

      Hey Scott, thanks much for sharing your experience with these 3 pieces of software. :)

      You reminded me that I responded to Katie’s question, which she posted elsewhere as well, and I forgot to put in my response here, so thanks for reminding me.

      Glad to hear that your experience with DAP has been good so far. I bet you’re glad the migration process is over though ;)

      Cheers!

  4. Lisa Van Ahn November 17, 2012 at 2:27 am #

    Forest,

    Cheers first and foremost. I love seeing you rock out a new launch and your posts are so helpful to me. I totally dig the new ‘super hero’ logo and honestly, you really are a tech super hero!

    So I have a question. I installed wishlist on a product that I have now launched twice successfully but am looking to “drip” with less work and effort on my part. It is really complicated in WL and I mostly end up doing it manually to not hit bugs.

    Here’s my question. Can I uninstall WL and switch to DAP without completely screwing up my website, the people that are already members, and all the content that is in there via WL?

    Thanks, Lisa-

  5. Walt January 22, 2013 at 8:03 pm #

    Forest,

    Your point about getting what you pay for is critical. If someone is trying to build a business, you want to use tools you can trust. DAP has excellent support and the product is excellent. If content dripping is part of your plan, DAP will give you the most flexibility and automation of any product I have tried.

    Walt

  6. Steve Dimmick January 30, 2013 at 10:29 pm #

    Hey Forest,
    I thought I would chime in with a few comments. I have been using Wishlist Member for the past 4 years and I am actually one of their Certified Developers (something DigitalAccessPass doesn’t have).

    Before I go any further, let me qualify myself and say I have use DAP as well for various client projects and it is an excellent product.

    When you say:
    “Wishlist Member does have the ability to drip content, but I’ve heard a lot of people say that they get frustrated with it because they can’t drip content the exact way they want to.”

    In what ways are people unable to drip content with Wishlist Member? I’m just curious because I find the Wishlist dripping system very easy to use. My only wish is that it allowed for dripping Pages. Right now it can only drip posts. So trying to drip pages using a theme like Optimize Press is a bit difficult with Wishlist Member.

    All software has bugs. Wishlist Member, Digital Access Pass, S2Member, all of them do. As a software developer it is just the nature of the “beast” as it were.

    As for support, my clients have always been happy with the timeliness of the support responses from Wishlist. I have also worked with Ravi and Veena from DAP and their support is outstanding too.

    For the past 18-24 months Wishlist Member software has been rock solid and dependable.

    I have worked with both of them and I like both of them. They have different strength’s and weaknesses and sometimes I recommend one over the other – but it depends on the client’s specific project and what is important to them.

    It does kind of sound like you have never used Wishlist Member. Restating what you have heard form others is fine, but if you really want to help your readers buy a copy of Wishlist and try it yourself.

    I hope you don’t take my comments the wrong way. I just thought I would offer a different perspective.

    I hope you decide to publish this comment.
    Regards,
    Steve

  7. Andrew March 27, 2013 at 7:16 pm #

    If you use Buddypress, DAP is not the best solution. But what is more upsetting, DAP Tech Support is really slow to non-responsive. If you have an issue, you will need to buy live support in advance. Once you bought it, tech support remains unsupportive. I purchased live support two weeks ago and still did not get a response as to when we can actually have the session. Run, don’t walk away from DAP.

    • Forest Linden March 28, 2013 at 12:42 pm #

      Thanks for sharing this, Andrew. That’s the first report I’ve heard of DAP support not being great. They’ve always responded quickly to my requests, but it’s good to know about your experience. If you have a moment, I’d love to hear about what problems you ran into between BuddyPress and DAP.

      Cheers :)
      Forest

  8. George May 1, 2013 at 12:01 am #

    What about kajabi as a platform? What are your opinions? I know it is alittle expensive but seems to have everything under one roof and organized well.

    I would love to know feedback from people who use or have used it.

    • Forest Linden May 2, 2013 at 1:41 pm #

      Hi George,

      thanks much for stopping by to leave a comment.

      I actually use Kajabi myself for my online programs. You can read more about what I think of Kajabi (compared to OptimizePress) in this post on my site: OptimizePress vs Kajabi

      Hope that helps a bit!

      All the best,
      Forest

Leave a Reply